The sales figure in your marketplace dashboard, the money that reaches your bank and the money you actually made are three different numbers. In this guide we pull them apart on a single order: marketplace fees, product cost, fulfillment, shipping, ads and returns.
The numbers here come from a fictional product, built on the fee structures Amazon and Etsy publish for US sellers. You can follow along by entering your own figures into the Marketplace Profit Calculator. Fees change by category, by country and over time, so take your own rates from Seller Central and from your Etsy payment account, not from this page.
The example product
One product, a $48 home object, sold two ways: on Amazon with Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA), and on Etsy, packed and shipped by the brand. Every cost below is fictional except the fee rates.
| Item | Amazon (FBA) | Etsy | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Item price | $48 | $48 | What the customer pays for the item |
| Shipping charged to the customer | $0 | $6 | Free shipping on Amazon; a flat rate on Etsy |
| Marketplace fee | 15% referral fee | 6.5% transaction fee | Amazon: Home and Kitchen. Etsy: on item price plus shipping |
| Payment processing | Included | 3% + $0.25 | Etsy Payments, US rate |
| Listing fee | None | $0.20 | Charged again each time the listing sells and renews |
| Fulfillment | $6.10 FBA fee | $7.50 label, $1.50 packaging | FBA fee assumed for a small, light item |
| Inbound shipping and storage | $1.30 | None | Per unit, assumed |
| Product cost | $14 | $14 | Landed cost per unit |
| Ads | $7 | $4 | Average per order |
| Return rate | 8% | 8% | Share of orders that come back |
On Amazon, the Professional selling plan adds $39.99 a month. Spread over 400 orders, that is $0.10 an order. Small, but put it in your sheet.
eBay and Walmart Marketplace follow the same logic: a percentage of the order that depends on the category, plus whatever you pay for fulfillment and ads. The rates differ; the method in this guide does not.
The sale price is not what you keep
On Amazon, the customer pays $48. Before you see any of it, Amazon takes the referral fee and the FBA fee. For one delivered order, the picture looks like this:
$12.40 of the $48 sale stays with you, a 25.8% margin. And this is the best case, before any returns.
The same product on Etsy, with $6 charged for shipping:
Etsy looks better per order, but the two are not the same job. On Amazon, the FBA fee buys storage, picking, packing, delivery and customer service. On Etsy, you do that work yourself. Compare the profit after you have priced your own time.
Why fees are bigger than they look
The headline rate is not what the marketplace takes. Three things make the real share larger.
Fees apply to more than the item. Amazon calculates the referral fee on the total sales price, including shipping and gift wrap. Etsy’s transaction fee and payment processing fee are both calculated on the order total, shipping included. Raising the shipping charge does not move money out of reach of the fee.
Rates change with category and price. On Amazon, jewelry pays 20% on the portion of the price up to $250 and 5% above it. Clothing and accessories pay 5% up to $15, 10% from $15 to $20 and 17% above $20. A price change that crosses one of these lines changes the rate, not just the amount.
Fees stack. On Amazon, the referral fee and the FBA fee together are:
(7.20 + 6.10) ÷ 48 = 27.7% of the sale price
On Etsy, the standard fees on this order are 10.3% of the order total. When the order comes through Etsy’s Offsite Ads, a further 15% of the order total is added (12% once your shop has made $10,000 in any 365-day period, capped at $100 per order):
- Offsite Ads fee (15%)$8.10
- Transaction fee (6.5%)$3.51
- Payment processing (3% + $0.25)$1.87
- Listing fee$0.20
- Left for product, shipping and profit$40.32
- Order total$54
After product cost, packaging and the label, that order leaves $17.32, about $4 less than the same order sold through Etsy Ads. You cannot set a budget for Offsite Ads, and once your shop passes the $10,000 threshold you cannot opt out. Plan your Etsy prices with this fee in them.
The rate in your dashboard does not tell you the total that was deducted. Your Amazon payment reports and your Etsy monthly statement list fees, fulfillment, ads, refunds and adjustments as separate lines. Splitting one month’s statement into these lines and dividing each by the number of orders shows the real deduction per order. For one marketplace client, this breakdown made the gap between the headline rate and the actual deduction visible for the first time.
Why returns hit your margin twice
When an Amazon order is refunded, the sale is reversed and the item usually goes back into stock. Amazon credits the referral fee, minus a refund administration fee: the lesser of $5 or 20% of the referral fee. What does not come back:
- The FBA fulfillment fee. The order was picked, packed and delivered.
- The ad spend. It was spent to win the order.
- The refund administration fee. $1.44 in this example.
In the example, one returned order costs you 6.10 + 7 + 1.44 = $14.54. A delivered order makes $12.40, so one return erases about 1.2 sales’ worth of profit. If the item comes back damaged and cannot be resold, add the $14 product cost. Amazon also charges a returns processing fee on products with high return rates in many categories.
On Etsy, a refund issued through Shop Manager credits the transaction and processing fees for the refunded amount. The listing fee, the packaging, the outbound label and the ad spend stay spent, and if your return policy covers the return label, so does that.
Use your actual return rate from the last three months, product by product, not a guess. Here is how the average profit per Amazon order changes with the return rate:
Going from no returns to 20% cuts profit per order by 43%. In categories where fit and expectation matter, such as clothing, shoes and jewelry, size charts, measurements and honest photos on the listing are a direct profit line.
Break-even price: the line you don’t cross
The break-even price is the sale price at which profit per order is zero. With return rate (r) and referral fee rate (c), the formula for the Amazon example is:
Break-even price = [(1 − r) × (product cost + inbound) + FBA fee + ads] ÷ [(1 − r) × (1 − c) − r × 0.2 × c]
The last term is the refund administration fee, as long as it stays under the $5 cap. Applied to the example:
- Top: 0.92 × (14 + 1.30) + 6.10 + 7 = 27.18
- Bottom: 0.92 × 0.85 − 0.08 × 0.2 × 0.15 = 0.7796
- Break-even price ≈ $34.86
Selling at $48, a price cut of about 27% takes profit to zero. A 20% deal price ($38.40) leaves about $2.76 per order; if the deal carries its own fee or pushes ad costs up, it loses money. Knowing this line before you set a price means you run promotions on purpose, not for volume.
Set the ad budget from margin
Setting ad spend as a share of revenue (“10% of sales”) is common, and wrong. The right question is: what is the most I can spend on ads to win one order?
The answer is your profit before ads. In the example, with an 8% return rate, average profit per Amazon order is $10.24 after $7 of ads. Add the ads back and $17.24 is this product’s ad ceiling per order. If every order came through ads, that is the same as a break-even ACoS of about 36%. Every dollar above the ceiling is a loss; as you approach it, sales grow and profit shrinks.
So plan ads product by product. High-margin products can carry a higher ceiling; low-margin products should not be grown with ads. Grouping campaigns by margin and giving each group its own cost ceiling is the simplest way to stop ads from eating profit. This is how we set up paid ads and marketplace programs at The Dizzy Co.
Checklist: what to look at every month
- Every product’s break-even price is in a sheet, and no deal price goes below it.
- Marketplace fees are tracked as a share of the full order, with fulfillment and Offsite Ads included.
- Return rate is calculated per product from the last three months.
- Ad budget is tied to product margin, not to revenue; each group has a cost ceiling.
- Each month’s statement is split into its lines, and the real deduction is compared with the headline rate.
Every calculation in this guide is on one screen in the Marketplace Profit Calculator. If you want a second pair of eyes on your marketplace numbers, get in touch.
Sources
- Amazon: Selling on Amazon fees and referral fee table
- Amazon: A guide to Amazon FBA fees
- Helium 10: Amazon seller fees (refund administration fee)
- Etsy: Fees & Payments Policy
- Etsy Help: Etsy fee basics
- Etsy Help: Payment processing fees
- Etsy Help: How Etsy's Offsite Ads work
- Etsy Help: How to issue a full or partial refund
Platform rules and rates change. This article was checked on 29 October 2026.
Related service: Marketing. We work like your marketing department: ads, email, marketplaces and content in one team, on one plan.




